PM promises change of approach to student tuition fees
The Prime Minister, Theresa May, has promised to review the whole system of student finance and has declined to rule out a switch to a graduate tax, in an interview ahead of the Conservative Party Conference.
Responding to mounting political pressure over the cost of university tuition fees, she said the party was changing its approach and would freeze the current increase in fees, leaving them at £9,250 (US$12,280).
She also said that the threshold at which graduates start paying their loans would be raised from £21,000 to £25,000. The change would cost £1.2 billion over four years, but there were no details on how the money would be found. It is expected this would be announced in the autumn budget.
The announcement was part of a series of measures pledged in a bid to shore up her political position and increase support among young voters who embraced the Labour Partys pledge to scrap tuition fees at the general election in June. The election left her without a majority and fighting for political survival.
Speaking to the BBC last Sunday, she said it had become clear that the level of debt students were leaving university with had become a matter of concern not just for the students themselves but for their parents and grandparents.
We have a system that provides funding for universities, that ensures more people can go to university, but people are worried about the level of debt that builds up so we will look at it again, she said.
But we are saying we are going to raise the threshold level at which you start to pay. For those that are able to take full benefit, it will be £30 a month more money into graduates’ pockets and we will scrap the intended increase in the level of fees.
When asked if this represented a U-turn on tuition fees, May said: No. What that policy has done is: there is money for universities, there are more students going to university. But when we set that policy, what we expected to happen is that we would have a range, a diversity in the system, that we would see universities offering shorter courses, universities offering courses at fees under the max of the fee; that hasnt happened. We have got to look at it again.
But when asked specifically if a graduate tax might replace the current system, she declined to rule it out.
She said: “By looking at it again we will be looking at the issues that people are raising, we will be looking at where the system has worked, we will be looking at the concerns that people have.”
‘Out of touch
Angela Rayner MP, Labours shadow secretary of state for education, said: The fact Theresa May thinks she can win over young people by pledging to freeze tuition fees only weeks after increasing them to £9,250 shows just how out of touch she is.
Another commission to look at tuition fees is a desperate attempt by the Tories to kick the issue into the long grass because they have no plans for young people and no ideas for our country. They are yesterdays party.
She said the next Labour government would scrap tuition fees entirely and introduce a National Education Service for lifelong learning for the many, not the few.
Responding to the prime ministers announcement, Universities UK, the vice-chancellors’ body, pointed to the need to redress the balance on student finance with more help for disadvantaged students by reinstating maintenance grants, which were scrapped under the previous Conservative administration led by David Cameron.
Alistair Jarvis, chief executive of Universities UK, said: The tuition fees system in England has allowed universities to offer a world-class education, provide the economy with highly skilled graduates, and transform the lives of students from all backgrounds, but it is right to look at ways to ensure it is affordable and fair.
He said Universities UK is pleased that the government will be looking at ways of addressing students money concerns, and raising the loan repayment threshold would put extra cash in the pockets of many graduates starting their careers.
But it would like the government to go further by reintroducing maintenance grants for those most in need and reducing interest rates for low and medium earners, he said.
We also need to do more to reverse the worrying decline in the numbers of part-time and mature students,” he added.
Sir Peter Lampl, chairman of the Sutton Trust education think tank, welcomed the planned raising of the repayment threshold and the freeze on fee increases.
But he said the government must go much further to make fees fairer and said it is right to set up a review.
Its a scandal that the poorest students graduate with the highest debt. Fees should be means tested so that those from low-income families repay less and maintenance grants should be reintroduced for the poorest students, he said.
A report for the Institute for Fiscal Studies published in the summer found that the poorest students often have to repay £57,000 (US$75,700) in debt.
The author of the report, Lord Adonis who was behind the original introduction of student fees at £3,000 each and complemented by loans with virtually no interest under Labour in 2004 said: Debt levels for new graduates are now so high that the Institute for Fiscal Studies estimates that three-quarters of graduates never pay it all back. The Treasury will soon realise it is sitting on a Ponzi scheme.
He contrasted the situation of students with that of vice-chancellors now earning salaries of £277,000 (US$368,000) on average and more than £400,000 (US$531,300) in some cases.
Tuition fee regime is no longer progressive, says IFS
Pledge to abolish university tuition fees needs honing
Labour party plans to abolish university tuition fees
Student satisfaction high despite tuition fee rises